Skip to main content

Corona Super-spreader at the Manor in UK

Recently a grave error was committed by the management of the Bhaktivedanta Manor towards its devotee community. About a week back or so devotees may have seen a video circulating on social media of H.H. Bhakti Purushottama Swami speaking in the Mayapur temple about how scores of devotees contracted the corona virus after a funeral and a series of programs held in the UK for a departed Vaisnava.

After he passed away several programs were arranged for H.G. Sruti Dharma Das with many devotees attending on 12th March as follows; 11:30am to 1:45pm at the Sri Krishna Haveli at Bhaktivedanta Manor, was Antima-sraddhanjali, or kirtan, offering flowers and final respects. The second, from 3 to 4pm at Saint Marylebone Crematorium in London, was the Antyeṣṭi-kriyā, or Ceremony of Cremation and lastly kirtan, from 7 to 9pm at the Sri Krishna Haveli. Further evenings of kirtan were planned at the same time for Friday, and Saturday, after and from 4 to 9pm on Sunday.
This means that there were 3 public programs held on that day and I am not sure if programs on the other days went ahead also. In order to put things in proper perspective regarding the Corona virus pandemic at the time, the timeline for the spread of the virus in the UK is given below:

31st January – first case of Corona in the UK
Early Feb – more cases
28th Feb – Transmission of Corona within UK
1 March – England, Wales, N. Ireland, Scotland had cases
3rd March – Declared as a level 4 emergency, which means coordinated at national level
11th March – WHO declared Corona a PANDEMIC. Some schools choose to close. A number of flight cancellations announced by airlines. Some retail outlets announce unusually large orders (hoarding).
12th March – The level of risk was raised in the UK from moderate to HIGH.

From January 2020 Vishakha Devi Dasi took over as the temple president. So she either planned or approved the programs held. Based on the progression of events above, how could anyone have organized public programs on 12th March in this dangerous circumstance and risk the lives of the lotus-like devotees? Devotees are not cheap but are very rare in this material world and dear to Krishna. We are meant to serve them and honour them, not risk their lives like this. The ISKCON NEWS site reported in this regard;

“The spread of the virus amongst the UK devotee community can be traced back largely to the March 12th funeral and March 15th memorial of Bhaktivedanta Manor temple president Srutidharma Das – the former of which drew about 1,000 people.”

               ISKCON NEWS 3rd April 2020

To put it plainly Vishakha Devi Dasi is responsible for the so far 5 deaths relating to Corona that took place and the 21 confirmed (maybe more now) infection cases. How many more will have to leave us?
The management or she may argue that it was before the restrictions on movement and social and religious gatherings were imposed by the UK govt, but the point here is lack of proper care and concern for devotees. We don’t need the government to tell us whether to risk the lives of the devotees. She most definitely would have known the situation concerning the corona virus and yet had no qualms putting all those children, women and old people, and the preaching mission at great risk by arranging or allowing the gatherings.

The devotee community has been engaged in preaching and they have made great achievements over the years holding phenomenal programs, bringing in new devotees and distributing books etc. Among the devotees who left due to corona infection related deaths were some exceptional devotees who did tremendous service for the Manor community.

The temple president’s role is not a light one just for prestige or fame, it has a very big responsibility attached with it. The whole congregation is in his, or in this case, her charge. The senior leaders of the UK yatra now owe it to the devotees to remove Vishakha Devi Dasi from the post of Temple President. This is for the safety of the lives of the congregation and the future of the Manor preaching mission. The temple President must be in tune with the goings on in the area and the world and have genuine concern for the devotees or it can lead to disaster. These incidents and their fallout has shown that she does not have the qualities to lead this great community and we cannot risk any further issues. We still don’t know how many more will end up leaving us. Actually in karmi society such a case of loss of lives would most certainly lead to litigation and perhaps this will need to be done if they do not agree to replace her.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chronicle of GBC Blunders: All 63 in a Single Article

By Nadiya Sasidhara Das Snippet:     The GBC has shown over the years that their decisions are unfortunately very often not based on Srila Prabhupada’s books and teachings and not based on Guru, Sadhu and Sastra (see list given below this article).     Recently the GBC passed a resolution permitting female diksha gurus (FDG’s) in ISKCON on 15th October 2019. It came as a great surprise and anguish to many. Surprise, because they did not properly discuss the issue, especially with the ISKCON India leaders who had requested for a dialogue on FDG with the GBC before any resolution on it. India contains 80% – 90% of the total number of ISKCON devotees in the world, so by not involving Indian leaders in this decision, the GBC effectively excluded 80 – 90% of ISKCON from this process. And anguish, as Srila Prabhupada’s vision of ISKCON establishing Varnasrama, although largely ignored all these years by the GBC seemed to now have been decidedly abandoned by it...
3 comments
Read more

RESPONSE to Seminar by Kaunteya Das titled; “How to mess up your life with Varnasrama” PART 1

Srila Prabhupada often said the religious process we are following is not Hinduism, but Varnasrama Dharma or Sanatana Dharma and he repeatedly glorified and stressed the necessity of establishing and following Varnasrama duties in his purports and lectures. Towards the end of his manifest presence, in his last instructions to his disciples and followers, he ordered us to ‘immediately’ establish Varnasrama colleges wherever our temples are, as a prerequisite to establishing Varnasrama. In other words, all temples, leaders and members of ISKCON should be working towards this. What to speak of Srila Prabhupada, Bhaktivinoda Thakura (the grandfather of ISKCON who pioneered the worldwide spread of the sankirtan movement) also wanted it and ordered his disciple and son Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Thakura to establish Varnasrama. So it was quite astounding and horrifying to see that Seminar no. 15 in this year’s Iskcon Leaders Sangha (ILS) 2020 held from 14 th – 20 th February at Mayapu...
Post a Comment
Read more

2019 Nov 25 Bureau FDG resolution

Whereas, the GBC has passed a resolution at their mid-term meeting at Tirupati 2019, authorizing female diksha gurus. However, the Bureau had passed a resolution during its February 2019  meeting at Pune, calling on the GBC not to pass any resolution on female diksha gurus, before entering into a dialogue with the Bureau, but regretfully GBC did not do so, and the Bureau feels distressed and disheartened by the disregard shown by the GBC towards the Bureau, Whereas, we all know that “books are the basis”, and in our foundational book, Srimad Bhagavatam, 4.12.32, Prabhupada clearly stated that “being a woman… Suniti could not be Dhruva’s diksha guru”.  The Bureau finds that the said resolution instituting female diksha gurus is in our understanding a contravention of this specific instruction of Srila Prabhupada,    Whereas, the resolution passed by the GBC on female  diksha gurus is having a divisive effect on the worldwide communities of devotees, ...
3 comments
Read more